Back to All Posts

S-Corp vs LLC for Small Business Owners: Which Saves More in Taxes?

Choosing the right business structure is one of the most important decisions you'll make as a small business owner. The choice between an S-Corporation (S-Corp) and Limited Liability Company (LLC) can literally save you thousands of dollars in taxes every year. At Passageway Financial, we've helped countless Minnesota and Wisconsin business owners navigate this critical decision, often saving them $6,000 or more annually through strategic entity selection.

Understanding the Basics: LLC vs S-Corp

What is an LLC?

A Limited Liability Company (LLC) offers personal asset protection while maintaining operational flexibility. LLCs are relatively simple to establish and maintain, making them popular among new business owners. However, from a tax perspective, single-member LLCs are treated as "disregarded entities" by the IRS, meaning all business income flows through to your personal tax return.

What is an S-Corp?

An S-Corporation is a tax election that can be made by LLCs or traditional corporations. This election fundamentally changes how your business income is taxed, potentially resulting in significant savings on self-employment taxes.

The Tax Implications: Where the Real Savings Happen

LLC Tax Treatment

With an LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship or partnership:

  • All net business income is subject to self-employment taxes (15.3% for Social Security and Medicare)
  • No distinction between salary and distributions
  • Simple tax filing but potentially higher tax burden

Example: If your construction company like Moderno Home Construction generates $100,000 in profit as an LLC, you'd pay $15,300 in self-employment taxes alone.

S-Corp Tax Advantages

With S-Corp election:

  • Only your reasonable salary is subject to payroll taxes
  • Additional profits can be distributed as dividends (not subject to self-employment tax)
  • Potential for significant self-employment tax savings

Example: That same $100,000 profit with a $50,000 reasonable salary would result in only $7,650 in payroll taxes – saving $7,650 annually.

Industry-Specific Considerations

Construction and Contracting Businesses

Companies like Country Creek Builders and Christian Brothers Construction often benefit significantly from S-Corp election due to:

  • High profit margins
  • Equipment depreciation benefits
  • Ability to justify reasonable salary based on industry standards

Our construction bookkeeping and accounting services help contractors maximize these benefits.

Landscaping and Outdoor Services

Seasonal businesses like Minnesota Landscapes and Plan Pools can use S-Corp structure to:

  • Smooth out income throughout the year
  • Take distributions during off-season without payroll tax burden
  • Maximize equipment and vehicle deductions

Learn more about our specialized landscaping contractor accounting services.

Specialty Contractors

Specialized contractors such as Fredrickson Masonry and Preferred 1 Concrete often see substantial savings through S-Corp election combined with proper tax reduction planning.

When S-Corp Makes Sense

S-Corp election typically benefits businesses that:

  • Generate consistent profits above $50,000 annually
  • Have predictable income streams
  • Can justify reasonable salary requirements
  • Want to minimize self-employment taxes

When LLC Might Be Better

Stick with LLC structure if you:

  • Have inconsistent or seasonal income
  • Want maximum operational flexibility
  • Have multiple owners with different profit-sharing agreements
  • Prefer simpler administrative requirements

The 'Reasonable Salary' Requirement

The IRS requires S-Corp owners who work in the business to pay themselves a "reasonable salary." This means:

  • Salary must reflect what you'd pay someone else to do your job
  • Too low salary invites IRS scrutiny
  • Industry standards matter significantly

For Minnesota contractors, reasonable salaries typically range:

  • General contractors: $60,000-$120,000
  • Specialty contractors: $50,000-$90,000
  • Landscaping contractors: $45,000-$75,000

Making the Switch: LLC to S-Corp Election

If you currently operate as an LLC, you can elect S-Corp tax treatment by filing Form 2553 with the IRS. Key considerations:

  • Election must be made by March 15th for current year treatment
  • Late elections are possible but require additional paperwork
  • Professional guidance ensures proper implementation

Beyond Entity Selection: Comprehensive Tax Strategy

Choosing between LLC and S-Corp is just one piece of effective tax reduction planning. Other strategies include:

  • Strategic equipment purchases and depreciation
  • Retirement plan contributions (SEP-IRA, Solo 401k)
  • Health Savings Account maximization
  • Family employment opportunities
  • Home office deductions

Real Estate Development and Investment

Companies like Arc Properties may benefit from different considerations:

  • Rental income treatment
  • 1031 exchanges for property investors
  • Depreciation recapture implications
  • Multi-entity structures for asset protection

Minnesota-Specific Considerations

Minnesota business owners should consider:

  • State conformity with federal S-Corp election
  • Minnesota's 9.85% top income tax rate
  • Local business licensing requirements
  • Workers' compensation implications

Working with Professional Guidance

The complexity of entity selection and tax optimization requires professional expertise. Our outsourced accounting services help Minnesota business owners:

  • Analyze their specific situation
  • Model tax savings scenarios
  • Implement optimal entity structure
  • Maintain ongoing compliance
  • Maximize year-round tax savings

Getting Started: Your Next Steps

  1. Analyze Your Current Situation: Review your business income, expenses, and tax burden
  2. Calculate Potential Savings: Model different scenarios based on your numbers
  3. Consider Operational Factors: Evaluate administrative burden vs. tax savings
  4. Consult Tax Professionals: Get personalized advice based on your specific circumstances
  5. Implement and Monitor: Make the election and track results

Conclusion

The choice between LLC and S-Corp can mean thousands in annual tax savings for Minnesota small business owners. While S-Corp election offers significant self-employment tax savings for profitable businesses, the decision depends on your specific circumstances, income level, and business goals.

At Passageway Financial, we've helped businesses across Minnesota – from Minneapolis contractors to Wisconsin manufacturers – optimize their entity structure and save substantial amounts in taxes. Our comprehensive approach combines entity optimization with year-round tax planning, expert bookkeeping, and CFO-level guidance.

Ready to explore whether S-Corp election could save your business thousands in taxes? Contact Passageway Financial today for a free consultation. Let us help you keep more of your hard-earned money and build a more scalable, profitable business.

More Posts

Minnesota Small Business Tax Planning Guide: Keep More of What You Earn in 2025

Check out these tips to save your Minnesota small business money on taxes.

Small Business Bookkeeping Mistakes That Cost You Money (And How to Fix Them)

Are you making these bookkeeping errors? Get tips on how to prevent these mistakes.

How Digital Marketing Agencies Can Reduce Taxes by $6,000+ Annually

Use these tips to save your digital agency thousands of dollars each year.

10 Tax Deductions Construction Contractors Miss Every Year

Stop overpaying in taxes! Make sure you make these key deductions.

Small Business Tax Deductions You're Probably Missing: A Complete Guide for 2025

Are you overlooking key tax deductions for your small business? Don't forget these essential deductions.

LLC vs S-Corp Tax Benefits: Which Business Structure Saves You More Money?

Should your business be an LLC or an S-Corp? Consider these factors!

Construction Business Tax Planning: How to Maximize Deductions and Minimize Liability

Maximize your construction business's taxes with these essential tips.

Small Business Quarterly Tax Payments: How to Calculate and Avoid Penalties

Get clarity on quarterly tax payments for your small business.

The Best Accounting Firms for Home Remodelers and Contractors

Stop overpaying on your taxes! Check out some of the top accounting firms for home remodeling and construction companies.

Top Tax Saving Tips for Home Remodelers and Contractors

Stop overpaying on your taxes. Use these essential tax-saving tips for remodelers and construction companies.

Tax Saving Tips for Custom Home Builders: Maximize Your Profits and Minimize Your Tax Burden

Home builders, stop losing money on your taxes. Use these tax-saving tips from our experts.

Top Tax Deductions for Pontoon Rental Businesses in Minnesota

Stop overpaying in taxes for your Minnesota pontoon rental business. Check out these essential tax deductions.

Simplify Payroll for Your Epoxy Flooring Crew: Avoid Headaches and Save Time

Simplify your payroll process and avoid costly mistakes. Learn how to streamline your epoxy flooring crew's compensation. Get started today!

Construction Business Valuation: What's Your Company Worth?

Determine the true value of your construction business. Get a professional valuation and understand your company's worth.

Best Accountants for Electricians (And Why Passageway Financial Is #1)

The best accounting firms for electrical contractors.

Smart Tax Planning Strategies for Electricians

Electrical contractors, stop overpaying on your taxes. Use these essential tax reduction tips.

Tax Strategies and Business Growth Hacks for Real Estate Professionals

Find out these top ways realtors can reduce their taxes.

Keys to Self-Employment Taxes: A Freelancer's Guide

Freelancers, get tax planning tips from our experts.

Client-Focused Accounting for Construction Businesses: Exceptional Service

Experience exceptional client service from a team dedicated to your construction business's success. Get personalized support and expert guidance.

Optimal Tax Deductions for Landscaping Contractors

See these must-know tips for how landscaping contractors can reduce their taxes.

Top-Ranked Tax Accountants for Construction Companies

Check out the top tax accountants for construction companies.

Top Bookkeepers for Landscape Contractors in Minneapolis

Top Bookkeepers For Minneapolis Landscape Contractors

Best Business Accountants and CPAs in Minneapolis St. Paul - Passageway

There's a huge difference between your typical Minneapolis, St. Paul business tax-preparing company and an outsourced accountant. Here’s what we think it takes to make the cut as one of the top ten high-caliber Certified Public Accountants and Tax Accountants for small businesses in Minneapolis and St. Paul.

10 Best Bookkeeping Services Near Minneapolis

Passageway Financial Tax & Accounting, based in Minneapolis, is a leading bookkeeping service providing guidance to help businesses become more profitable and scalable.

Understanding LLC vs. S-Corporation for Landscaping Contractors

Learn the tax difference between an LLC and S-Corp for Landscaping contractors.

12 Tips for Finding the Right CPA for Your Business: A Guide for Digital Marketers

Needing a new CPA or Chartered Accountant? We go over the 12 best tips to help finding the right CPA or Chartered Accountant for your digital marketing agency.

Must-Do Bookkeeping Tips for Landscapers

Check out these tips from our CPA's on how to keep your landscaping company's books compliant.

Beyond Tax Day: Maintain a Productive Relationship with Your Twin Cities Tax Accountant All Year

Just because Tax Day is over doesn't mean you should stop working with your tax accountant. Find out why year-round tax planning services is beneficial.

Best Outsourced Accounting Firms Near Golden Valley, MN

Check out the top Golden Valley, MN small business accounting firms.

5 Tips on How to Choose a Small Business Accountant

This article will equip you with 5 different things you should be looking for when choosing a certified public accountant for your small business.

10 Best Bookkeeping Services Near Brooklyn Park

We outline 10 of the best bookkeepers in or near Brooklyn Park that take the time with each client to learn about their wants and needs.